The Psychology Behind Your Car Insurance Choices

With lots of companies selling car insurance, it’s tough to pick the right one for you and your family.

They all claim to be the best, which can make things confusing. But even though the policies might seem alike, there are some important differences to think about.

Your goal is to find one that gives you all the benefits you need at a fair price but making car insurance choices requires a lot of digging and emotional biases.

You may dismiss this argument with the conclusion that’s required to make the right auto insurance choices is ensuring on cost, type of insurance policies, and cheapest auto insurance.

— But what determines that overall decision?

Find out about the psychology behind Your Car Insurance Choices, the emotional biases, and the way of bypassing them for more logical choices.

What is a Car Insurance Policy?

Car insurance is a deal between you and an insurance company.

You pay them money regularly, called premiums, and they promise to help you out financially if something bad happens to your car, like an accident or damage.

Here’s what car insurance can cover:

  • Fix your car or someone else’s car if you crash into them.
  • Paying for damage to other people’s property or if someone gets hurt because of an accident you’re in.
  • Helping with medical bills or funeral costs if people get hurt or die in an accident you’re involved in.

Benefits of car insurance:

Car insurance has a lot of advantages, especially when you get into an accident.

If you don’t have insurance, you have to pay for all the damages by yourself and deal with everything that happens afterward on your own.

Here are some benefits:

  • Insurance saves you money, especially in big accidents, with the average yearly cost in the US around $935.80 compared to potential thousands in losses from a single crash.
  • It helps maintain the value of your vehicle and prolong its lifespan, mitigating losses from events like hailstorms through comprehensive coverage.
  • Having insurance provides peace of mind, ensuring you can afford repairs and protect your family from financial losses.
  • Insurance protects you from lawsuits and covers legal costs if you’re sued for damages caused by an accident.
  • Some insurance companies offer a no-claim bonus (NCB) as a discount on premiums for each claim-free year, making car insurance more affordable over time.

How does car insurance work:

Auto insurance works by providing financial protection in case of accidents or other damages involving your vehicle.

When you pay a premium, the insurance company agrees to cover your losses according to the terms of your policy.

Policies are tailored to your needs and budget, with options to customize coverage amounts.

They typically last for six or 12 months and can be renewed.

Most states require basic coverage, such as bodily injury liability and property damage liability, which cover costs for injuries, death, or property damage caused by you or another driver operating your car.

Some states also mandate medical payments or personal injury protection (PIP) coverage, which pays for medical expenses, lost wages, and related costs for you and your passengers.

Car Insurance Choices

What Does Car Insurance Cover?

The specific things your insurance covers depend on the rules in your state and any extra coverage you choose to add.

In almost every state, except New Hampshire, you’re required to have a minimum amount of coverage for things like injuries and property damage.

If you don’t get the minimum car insurance that your state says you need, you could get in big trouble. 

Your license might get taken away, you could be fined, or if it keeps happening, you might even end up in jail.

Types of Car Insurance Policies and Coverage

Here’s a breakdown of what each coverage type includes:

Bodily injury (BI) liability insurance:

  • Covers medical costs and lost wages for people in the other vehicle(s) when you’re responsible for an accident.
  • Pays for your legal expenses, settlements, and judgments if you’re sued over an accident.

Property damage (PD) liability insurance:

  • Pays for damage to the other driver’s vehicle or other property (like a fence) when you cause an accident.
  • Covers your legal costs, settlements, and judgments if you’re sued due to an accident.

Uninsured motorist coverage (UM):

  • Covers your medical expenses, lost wages, funeral costs, and other expenses if an uninsured driver hits you.
  • In some states, it may cover your property damage too.

Underinsured motorist coverage (UIM):

  • Pays for your medical bills, lost wages, funeral costs, and other expenses if a driver with insufficient insurance hits you.
  • May cover your property damage in some states.

Collision coverage:

  • Covers the cost to repair or replace your car if you’re in an accident, like hitting another car, tree, or pole.

Comprehensive coverage:

  • Pays to repair or replace your car for issues like theft, vandalism, floods, fire, hail, and other problems.

Medical Payments (MedPay):

  • Covers medical bills for you and your passengers no matter who’s at fault for an accident.

Personal Injury Protection (PIP):

  • Covers medical expenses, rehabilitation, lost wages, funeral costs, and other expenses for you and your passengers, regardless of fault.
  • Required in no-fault insurance states.

Additional Car Insurance Policies:

Car insurance companies offer extra coverage options to customize your policy. Here are some common ones:

  • Accident forgiveness: If you cause a crash, this coverage stops your rates from going up. Usually, you get one forgiven accident per policy for a set time, like every three years.
  • Gap insurance: It pays the difference between what you owe on your loan or lease and the insurance payout if your car is wrecked or stolen. For instance, if you owe $25,000 but your car’s value is $22,000, gap insurance covers the $3,000 difference.
  • Rental reimbursement insurance: When your car’s in the shop for a covered problem (like an accident), this covers rental or public transport costs.
  • Rideshare insurance: If you drive for companies like Lyft or Uber, there might be gaps in coverage when you’re on the way to pick up a passenger. Rideshare insurance fills that gap.
  • Roadside assistance insurance: If you’re stuck with a flat tire or dead battery, this covers services like towing, refueling, locksmithing, and jump-starting.

Car insurance doesn’t cover:

  • Personal items: Like cell phones, purses, or computers stolen from your vehicle. These are usually covered by your homeowners or renters insurance.
  • Items not permanently installed: Such as GPS or stereo equipment.
  • General wear and tear: Normal deterioration of your car isn’t covered.
  • Mechanical breakdowns: Insurance doesn’t pay for repairs due to mechanical issues.
  • Business use: If you’re using your car for work, you’ll need commercial auto insurance.
  • Intentional damage: Damage caused on purpose isn’t covered.
  • Driving in Mexico or abroad: While some U.S. policies offer coverage in Canada and parts of Mexico, driving in other countries typically isn’t covered.
  • Remaining loan balance: If your car is totaled and the value is less than what you owe, gap insurance covers the difference.

The Psychology Behind Your Car Insurance Choices

Six thinking biases could mess with your decisions when you’re shopping for car insurance.

Let’s seek them plus tips and tools to fight these biases so that you can make smarter buying choices easily.

#1. Friend Bias:

It’s common to ask friends and family for advice when picking car insurance.

But sometimes, you might trust them too much, even if it’s not the best choice.

Instead of just going with their advice, try getting at least three quotes from different types of insurance companies.

Use a quote tool to find companies that suit your needs best.

#2. Fear Bias:

If you’ve had a crash before and had to pay for repairs, you might worry it’ll happen again.

This fear could push you to buy more insurance than you need. To avoid overspending, figure out what coverage you need based on your risks.

Start with your state’s minimum requirements and add more if needed to protect your stuff without breaking the bank.

#3. “I Know it All Syndrome”:

Ever made up your mind about something without knowing all the details? That’s called the Dunning-Kruger effect.

For example, you see a car insurance ad on TV and decide it’s not worth considering without really checking it out.

To avoid this mistake, check out lots of insurance options, even ones you’ve already judged.

Compare what they offer and any discounts they have. The more you look into it, the better decision you’ll make.

#4. Too Many Choices:

Let’s say you’ve been looking at different insurance plans for days and now you’re in a hurry to pick one.

You might just go with your home insurance company’s plan because they offer a discount for bundling. 

Discounts are nice, but don’t let them be the only reason you choose. To make things easier, try using an online tool that compares insurance quotes and reviews.

It’ll help you find the right plan without all the hassle.

#5. Decisions by Emotion:

You might lean towards choosing an insurance policy based on how well the company has done for your investments.

But making decisions based purely on emotions, like how much you like a company, can lead to mistakes. 

Instead, look at practical stuff like how much you can save on your insurance each month or year with things like deductibles and discounts. 

By checking out different options, you could find a good deal while still managing your money smartly.

#6. Not Willing to Learn New Things:

If you like paying your auto insurance annually with a credit card for the rewards, you might stick with that even if it’s not the best option anymore.

But it’s better to weigh up all your choices before deciding. Instead of just looking for the cheapest option or sticking with what you know, think about different ways to cut down on your insurance costs.

This way, you can find a great policy that fits your needs while still enjoying the perks of paying with your credit card.

Best Car Insurance Companies in Europe

#1. AXA SA:

AXA SA is a company that offers insurance and asset management services.

They have different parts of their business called segments. These include France, Europe, Asia, AXA XL, the United States, International, and Transversal & Central Holdings.

In Europe, they work in Switzerland, Germany, Belgium, the United Kingdom & Ireland, Spain, and Italy doing Life & Savings and Property & Casualty activities.

#2. Zurich Insurance Group:

Zurich AG is a company that provides insurance products and related services. It has different parts of its business called segments.

These include Property and Casualty Regions, Life Regions, Farmers, Group Functions and Operations, and Non-Core Businesses. 

Zurich is known for its reliable car insurance products and services, serving customers in multiple European countries.

#3. Generali:

Assicurazioni Generali SpA provides insurance and financial products. It has three main parts of its business: Non-Life, Life, and Holding & Other Business.

The Non-Life segment covers motor and non-motor businesses, including motor third-party liabilities, casualty, accident, and health.

It also offers sophisticated covers for commercial and industrial risks and complex plans for multinational companies.

The Life segment includes savings and protection businesses for individuals and families.

Generali was founded on December 26, 1831, and is based in Trieste, Italy.

#4. Aviva:

Aviva is the biggest life insurance company in the UK, holding a hefty 23% share of the market there.

This strong position allows them to offer a variety of products covering Insurance (health & protection), Wealth, and Retirement (IWR).

More than ever, Aviva helps customers protect themselves and their families.

They assist individuals in saving and achieving financial security, either directly or through intermediaries.

When it comes to insurance, Aviva is the only major provider in the UK, offering protection and health coverage for both individuals and businesses.

How To Buy Make Car Insurance Online

Getting car insurance can take up your time, but it doesn’t have to. 

Here’s  how to simplify buying car insurance online:

#1. Get Information:

  • Provide details about yourself, the vehicles, and any additional drivers.
  • Include names, addresses, and birth dates for all drivers.
  • Specify the year, make, model, and VIN for each vehicle.
  • Note any accidents or traffic tickets from the past three to five years.
  • Review your current insurance policy for comparison.

#2. Check Coverage Needs:

  • Understand your state’s minimum requirements for liability coverage.
  • Example: Connecticut requires $25,000 bodily injury per person, $50,000 total bodily injury per accident, and $25,000 property damage per accident.
  • Consider additional coverage for accidents involving underinsured drivers.

#3. Enter Data and Choose Preferences:

  • Fill out online forms with vehicle and driver information.
  • Select desired coverage options based on your budget and vehicle value.
  • Options may include glass replacement, rental car payment, and roadside assistance.

#4. Compare Quotes:

  • Request quotes from multiple insurers to compare rates.
  • Some tools provide quotes from various insurers, facilitating comparison.
  • Adjust coverage options to see how rates change.
  • Examine reviews to identify reliable providers.

#5. Read Reviews:

  • Research insurance providers online for customer feedback and ratings.
  • Look for prompt claims response and accessible customer service.

#6. Finalize Your Policy:

  • Once satisfied with a deal from a trusted provider, proceed with the purchase.
    • Complete any required documentation or verification processes.
    • Download and print insurance cards for immediate coverage.

Is Buying Car Insurance Online Cheaper?

  • Online quotes may offer lower rates due to fewer overhead costs.
  • However, agents can provide insight into discounts not easily accessible online, potentially saving money.

Pros and Cons of Purchasing Car Insurance Online:


  • Speedy process for obtaining multiple quotes and comparing costs.
  • The convenience of shopping at any time without constraints.
  • Immediate coverage upon purchase.


  • Limited ability to ask questions compared to in-person interactions.
  • Possible follow-up calls or emails for sales purposes.
  • Discounts may be overlooked without agent assistance.


Getting a new car is exciting. With its shiny exterior, low mileage, and that new car smell, driving it off the dealer’s lot feels amazing.

But buying insurance for your new ride may not be as fun due to emotional biases that may affect your auto insurance policy choices.

You don’t have to let these thinking traps mess up your auto insurance decisions.

Stay woke while you shop for coverage so that you can spot when you’re being swayed by biases and use the tips from this article to make a better choice.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *